[Mafia Won] Back to the Basic II: Hard Boiled

[andracass]

[Vote] Detective

[No Lynch]

[cicada]

[vote] Psychologist.

[no lynch]

 

We can always change our lynch votes if something stands out, right?

[Walpurgis]

[Vote] Detective

[Eliminate] ZeroPassion

[Mr. Knightly]

[Vote] Detective

[No Lynch]

 

Given the fact that most of us are just vanilla townies and that we need to make three posts we will need to deduce who is mafia by what is said. Everyone will need to contribute.

[Cataline]

[vote] Psychologist.

Let's all start talking!! Come on kids, even in prison we should be happy to socialize!

[andracass]

Why are the people who are lynching opting to lynch?

[Alaris]

On second thought: [Unvote] Detective [Vote] Psychologist

 

I agree with you, it's better to get any clue before that person is killed.

 

And I second Andracass: I may understand Lía's vote, but not the one from ZeroPassion. Was it simply random?

[Bok Choi]

Okee let's do this

[vote] Psychologist

[no lynch] for now.

[cicada]

I'd like to hear about Zero's vote, if possible. Maybe it was random, but maybe it had a different meaning.

[Daniel Blackworth]

@purplecicada I assume it was random, considering that we don't have any info pre-game.

 

I don't really like those who have indicated no lynch even as a temporary vote. I think it's best for us to try to vote because it generates discussion which can help us progress in scumhunting.

 

For now, [Eliminate] L'Belle. I didn't quite like the way they voted no lynch on a separate post. ((It's actually an empty reason lol, but consider it temporary)

[Daniel Blackworth]

On the Detective / Psychologist discussion, each option has it's particular positive effects and drawbacks.

 

Detective is a role which checks if someone's committed murder and is best utilized late-game where certain players (mafia/vigilante) have already committed the night kill. As for the Psychologist, it is a role which checks if someone's capable of murder, but hasn't committed it yet. I believe it is best utilized early game where certain players (mafia/vigilante) have yet to perform a kill.

 

I think going from that Psychologist is better because the chances of it being utilized is greater rather than Detective which may die before it can get a result.

 

[Vote] Psychologist

[Mr. Knightly]

@Mazino Divergent Ah thanks or clarifying what the roles did. I was unsure hence I placed my vote as I did  

 

[Unvote] Detective 

[Vote] Psychologist

[Chickens]

THAT GUY IS UGLY

[vote] DETECTIVE

[ELIMINATE] KNIGHTLY

 

I am a hard boiled egg...

[Paul25]

I believe as well that psychologist will yield better results than that of detective.

Thus:

Vote: Psychologist

 

lel, I see that Zero votes me first off. 

Unsure, why they did it. Perhaps, that's just an arbitrary one. 

Hence, I'll OMGUSS them:

 

Eliminate: ZeroPassion

[ZeroPassion]

The only possible reason I voted Paul was because I could see the future

 

The future in which Paul is scum

[ZeroPassion]

I'm having trouble quoting for some reason, but

 

@Mr. Knightly I'm not a fan of your opening post w/ the "everyone needs to contribute" blurb. Comes off as an obvious duh post that can skate by. Come and contribute then. 

 

@Cataline u start talking then >:]

[L'Belle]

I agree with Dive completely and believe we should go with his idea.

[Paul25]

Thanks for your probable reason. 

But,

Unfortunately, your prediction is wrong. That's all I can say.

[Daniel Blackworth]

@ZeroPassion Why Paul out of 12 other players? Did RNG call him forth?

 

@andracass Why did you just start out with voting without any context?

 

@Walpurgis Why the immediate vote on ZeroPassion without asking him or saying anything about the vote?

 

@Cataline Why did you just suggest for everyone to talk, but not generate discussipn yourself?

 

@Bok Choi Same question with Andracass

 

@Psychic Sheep Why Knightly amongst 12 people too?

 

@Paul25 Why OMGUS them?

 

I think those are some important questions to ask.

[Daniel Blackworth]

Additionally this,

 

@L'Belle Why did you not respond in any way to my vote? It's not necessary, but feels weird. Also, why did you simply say you agree and not really say anything else?

[andracass]

@Mazino Divergent ...............tbh i'm a little distracted with other things right now.

I think it's too early to lynch, and think that the detective would be better suited for finding killers.

[Chickens]

Its been so long since I've see knightly be mafia

 

 

 

[Daniel Blackworth]

@Psychic Sheep You contradict yourself. He was Mafia in Mafia: What Lurks Below and you were playing with him until near the game ended.

[Cataline]

Cause I thought everyone started to ignore that"

And I'm not good w knowing wtf should we talk about man this plan backfired

But ok hi I'm Cat aaand I'm totally probably a townie. Whether or not vanilla waits to be seeeeen

We're supposed to learn how to read scummies with this very basic set buuuut I dunno how people usually do this. I think I'm good w considering all possibilities and spamming mods for the rules, but when it comes to committing to voting against a person I tend to hesitate..  And can't really pick town from maf. Then again I'm like, never town. I midkey want to lynch someone D1 but it is oh so easy for someone in the mafia to slip in the shadows. Rip..

[L'Belle]

@Mazino Divergent Oh well I kind of didn't see that until you mentioned it now lol. The main reason I did that was because I forgot to do it in the first post.