alright, im here and ready to go full in on this one. bear with me.
- eevee/eeveelutions and riolu. so whoever knows me a bit, absolutely knows I despise seeing these pokemon appear in fanfictions, especially as starters. the reason for that is quite simple- im sick of seeing them. theyre literally EVERYWHERE in fanfictions. whenever the main character announces 'I have a different starter pokemon' or 'im going to catch my starter pokemon myself' or even 'my starter pokemon was abused and I nursed it back to health', in 90% of the cases that very same starter is eevee or riolu (to a lesser extent ralts). main characters in pokemon fanfics literally start out more often with eevee or riolu than with actual starter pokemon. sure, the aura is a cool concept and everything, and sure, the concept behind eevee was rather cool. but theyve been used so much now that just seeing an eevee or a lucario gives me major headaches, and thats not even only talking fanfictions. the ironic thing is that a lot of those very same people complain about pikachu being overused by gamefreak, while at the same time the pokemon fanbase abuses lucario and eevee much harder than gamefreak could ever have used pikachu.
- speaking of lucario. remember that one movie in which a lucario was able to talk? yeah? that was cool, wasnt it? yeah, now every trainer in the world who has a bond with their riolu/lucario can talk to those too in fanfics. disregard the fact that every single other lucario that has ever appeared in the anime, games or wherever could not talk for a bit, because I have a bond with my lucario and that means im able to talk to them. it doesnt matter that korrina, who had such a tight bond with her lucario that she was able to mega evolve it, wasnt able to talk to it. and the worst is that the reasoning is always the same- tight bond, we can talk. god, at this point just say that the aura your riolu/lucario uses is stronger than the average or something. that honestly isnt much better, but im so done with seeing this 'tight bond' stuff, especially if said tight bond develops in goddamn chapter 4 or something.
- your main character never did well in any classes or something, and was never really remarkable. thats a good thing, now youve made sure theyre not a gary stu or a mary sue. oh, and now they received their starter pokemon, which is imported from another region. and now they can start their pokemon journey to meet lots of new pokemon but for unspecified reasons only bond with the rarest of them while not losing a single battle ever. if this sounded okay to you, I want to beg you to reconsider.
- speaking about the 'rare pokemon' stuff, why does every random trainer in your story have things like rattata or pidgey or even stuff like kadabra, sandslash or onix? thats because theyre not too rare and thus should made sense for the trainers to have, right? then why in the name of the lord does your main character have a team that consists of charizard, venusaur, blastoise, vaporeon, dratini and I dont know what else? because theyre the main character? if your main character is as happy to finally be able to go on their pokemon journey and befriend all pokemon, then why in the name of the lord do they not catch a random rattata or caterpie and instead wait for the first rare pokemon to appear?
- nicknames are a weird concept in fanfictions. your main character(s) use them, but literally everyone bar maybe your rivals dont. why? who will ever know, man. who will ever know.
I dont have much time left so ill cut it short for now, but next up ill be focusing on the worst cliches of them all. the ones that still make me shake in anger every time I read them.
betrayal ash fanfiction cliches.
partly agree, partly disagree. yeah, its harder to give your pokemon a character due to this, but at least you can try. make a chapter centered around one specific pokemon (not counting the chapter you catch said pokemon in) or something. ive literally seen fics that fully go 'pokemon are friends and equals and' yada yada yada, and then proceed to only focus on the human characters and go full 'oh and on the way charmander evolved into charmeleon and learned metal claw'. like, at least specify how that happened. jesus christ, its not that hard.