Okiedokie, inspired by a certain excellent thread on writing critism, I decided to give it a go.
And to start it off, I will parrot everything Code: PIRULUK (what a fucking awesome name) said. It does bother me a bit that it is script format... And yet isn't script format. Script format is harder to read to begin with than a regularly formatted story, so I do think you should take it all the way if you wanna to stick with it.
Secondly... I think you should go back and edit the the earlier posts as well to make the text smaller. I had to copy this entire thing into Evernote and then manually cut away all dates and usernames that came with it, and god knows I don't like to put effort into anything. It'd be for your own sake too; you haven't gotten that many reviews, and I absolutely believe that is partly because people look at your story and think "WOAH there I can't read this."
Then, onto the actual reviewing. Some of these things are just what went through my head reading this, rather than things you need to change thou.
First paragraph; it's campy. I love campy. Keep it mostly intact, but mind that Pokémon is spelled, well, Pokémon, capital letter and apostrophe above the e. Also, this sentence was confusing to me, but that might just be my lack of caffeine.
"As the societies progress, questions find themselves at the forefront of conversation “do we treat pokemon properly” or what should we expect of pokemon."
First paragraph ends with "This is the story of Justin Wayland". Second paragraph ends with "This is his story". I say give both these sentences a weapon each and unleash them on a small island - only one can survive.
All Pokémon species should be capitalized too, see: Cacnea.
The man is Justin Wayland a normally upbeat individual focused mainly on the moment rather than stressing the “will be’s”.
Commas are awesome, just saying.
"Next to him is a man wearing a black trench coat and matching fedora."
sounds like the kind of dude that you don't want near playgrounds.
I love the dialogue, Justin is hilarious.
"There are more than just challenges to be considered here. I can take you home before such dangers present themselves."
You're going through the desert in a trench coat. The guy beside you is wearing a t-shirt. You just offered to "take him home". The only danger here is you.
"Justin (inching closer to the entity)"
NO Justin step away from him!!
"Great. Then I’m safe."
NNoooo
"places a pokeball on his lap"
HANDS OFF LAP
Julia
DID YOU SEE THE BOOMIE
Justin
My clothes are burnt miss, so yes. I most certainly did see the boomie. Please tell me you aren’t an EMT.
Julia (shaking Justin while smiling)
NOPE. I’m a gym leader!
Justin
That’s actually far more unsettling.
I love this guy. Justin for president.
"You got boomied bad."
Okay, as much as Julia does love her explosions, and does to some extent talk like this, she's starting to sound like a pre-schooler, so maybe tune it down a lil bit?
"The league runner who invited you here."
Manager. Ame is a bit iffy too, but I haven't seen enough of her in the game to comment on it, so keep at it.
"Shade."
Huh. I didn't think it was Shade 'cause he spoke in such concrete sentences and wasn't floating.
"Freaking out rarely solves problem. I’m no genius but even I can figure that out. At the very least even if I can’t fight them, I should know who to avoid right?"
Super douchy sentence, he sounds patronizing. That might be what you're going for, but I like Justin, so it bother me, haha.
"Hi, I’d like one pokeman please."
Like he's at a fucking drug store, go J.
"Victoria
Hello, I’m Victoria."
I mean, sure, I got that that was Viktoria, but there for a non-Reborn reader, you might wanna draw a stronger connection between the woman in kimono and her saying this line.
"Only person with a last name around here."
HAH.
"Justin begins laughing hysterically and his laugh can be heard all throughout the grand hall."
This just sounds... Unhinged.
"That’s the one that becomes the kick-boxing chicken right?"
Uh-huh no mentions of real life animals.
"As Justin screams unintelligibly the torchic chirps along with him as the two are clearly screaming in approval of each other."
The last sentences of Justin are sounding very... Comic-like, screaming and laughing hysterically for several lines which sort of takes a away from the tone of it all.
Cain
Sorry to hear that. I’ll see you around new best buddy.
Ooookay. This sentence. I'm wary. On one hand, it isn't that bad. I might just be reading into it. But it sounds a little bit like you just slapped a big fat "no homo, bro" on Cain, and that's sorta rubbing me the wrong way.
"It’s a pokepokegear. Pretty much lets you speak into it and shows me in text and vice versa. When you get good with the language and evolve to have hands then you can type into it and boom we can fight without ever saying a word. Helpful since announcing “Blaze use fireblast” generally gets people on the defensive. So…. Lets get to it."
I have a hard time with gimmicks like this; they always show up, and they rarely contribute with anything else than making the protag super special. Also, you're just gonna write during a battle? Seriously? And the Pokémon too? Uhm, moving on, I guess.
"She’s probably a fire type so it should be easy for you."
A guy so strategy-focused can't bother to look up the first gym leaders type, even though her gym is the biggest building in the city? Hm. Also, fire vs fire doesn't exactly equal easy, especially if she has six Pokémon and you have one.
"Justin
You’re buddy I’m guessing."
??
Shelly
Hi… its um… nice to meet you…
YASS my homegirl Shelly.
So I guess that's it. I'm a little on the edge on his weird gear and the writing Torchic, but on the other hand, I love Justin as a character, he cracks me up. Can't wait for him to verbally trash Fern to smithereens. gg man.