see I agree with Ame that its outdated but i do see potential in it , and I dont believe it will be confusing because someone will start a topic and as the topic goes people will change it and I didnt say merge them all as one necceserily .. more like instead of there being 20 of them put them toegther as like 5 or six
The other day I just put a small post about blastoise vs charizard vs venasuar and the topic was kept busy for quite a while , I think people do want to compete and challenge pokemon against each other like a free debate with unknown and random strategies and ideas .
and I like nichcrash's starting idea because cmon who doesnt want to talk about it , Id be willing to bet atleast 15 people would reply and protest if i said caterpie could win magmortar... and i do