Anti_Hero

I wanted to talk with the dead and now I am able to. Satoshi do you hear me? I hope you aren't lonely anymore Unicorn Jesus? I am coming to you ?

Don't do it, the mafia knows who the mafia are, ergo knows who is detective. If we do it, after 2-3 nights they will start killing the good detectives

Right now it's impossible About half should have got mafia the other half should have got inocent In a night or 2 it would be beneficial, also if we kill a detective that is same or insane and when know who they investigated and what they got then it would be more beneficial, but in that case it would be the last game all over again only that the mafia would be able to tell if they are correct and thus kill them before they do too much damage

I think it's a bad idea. The mafia gains more knowledge too. Once it is fine, but more than once makes you a target

As other said since I investigated quinnox it would tell me if I was right or wrong I think you are right but the problem would be the mafia, I personally would prefer it being randome. And I may change my vote depending how things go We can't be sure of anything, you might be mafia, confused or one of the other bad detectives, as you may be a good one, as any of us could be. I just voted on you for the sake of voting and since I at this moment can only trust in myself (till I discover I am a bad detective ) As I said, I would prefer not to kill quinnox. Since I only know that Im not one of the bad types (2 remain that I can be)

Then there is no way to know for certain or to have at least a hunch I will vote on Quinnox. My reason, I investigated quinnox last night and this would get me more information. I myself would prefer if quinnox didn't die (a good player shouldn't die) but this would give me an advantage. I wouldn't mind the randome kill either but for that I would have to vote on someone too... eliminate - quinnox Please note that I don't want quinnox to die...

@Monsieur Divergent what will happen if everyone has one vote? What happens if there isn't a majority voting for a specific target? For example 3 votes for one person and the rest with 0-2votes

The only way we could get certain information would be to investigate ourselves (that Monsieur don't allow) to investigate someone who is going to die. (Luck based) And since we don't know how many there are from each type we should expect the worst Now about the distribution, I would assume that there are at least 5 mafia members this time, because I believe this time we have more than last (I think someone said that there where few mafia in comparation to the rest of us) If we assume that it's trust we should have at least the same number of good detectives (since they are the only ones useful) making them 5-6, we are 18 making 7-8 useless detectives , they would be around 2-3 It is even possible to that it's not that proportional since the design of the game favors the mafia. But this information Another note, if by some chance you discover you are a useful detective don't reveal yourself so fast. If there are at least 5 mafia and you reveal yourself at the first it will be hard for the rest of us.

Even if more people investigated him, we could be any type... We would get about half with town and other half with mafia (the only info we could get is how the roles are distributed, and even that is far fetched)

is not quite the same but yes it would make things easier. we dont need to reveal what we got, meaning every one would only benefit that much as they can think of. the problem is, we have to loose one turn and we would have to sacrifice someone. And I myself dont agree with doing this, I am just saying this is a possibility

we also could assign someone to investigate (all of us will investigate that person) and next day we kill that person. here is why, everyone wil exclude at best 2 possibilities for their role. Note that I dont agree with this sacrifice idea but its an option. or we all reveal what we investigated for that person, of course that we dont get much information only after that person is dead or we know what we are... to know if we are randome we can always investigate several times the same person. for example our first try we got mafia (we are or paranoid, or true detective or always wrong or randome) if we investigate other people and get inocent then we could exclude paranoid, but never the other 2, randome can only be excluded after some people died or if we investigated 2 times the same person and we got diferent results. meaning that at best we need 2 more nights to be certain we are a usefull detective and with luch we know witch of the 2 Eddit: Note that of we know how many mafia there are we can after several nights (most likely end game) know for certain what we are

I agree with the last part, the people who investigated him will know if they where right or wrong , either way excluding 2 types of detectives they are That is why it would be clever to investigate yourself but as Monsieur said, it isn't possible

If we don't want to vote we can always choose anyone at randome, for example I chose candy (just an example and because you are right above me) then every other person chooses someone else, meaning every character gets one vote so no one is killed Of course this is to get a bit more time to get information. No one is obligated to follow

I am sorry Then it would be [Answer] Question (A) I disagree. The only thing the mafia knows is that they are X people. They don't know how many detectives there are and there are 3 types of detectives that are bad, the one that appears always as inocent, the one that appears always mafia and the one that is randome . The other types are dangerous for the mafia since they can get information out of it. And we don't know if there is one type with 5 detectives and the rest with 2 ( this is an example) we can't just assume we aren't that type just because satoshi was that one. This is the information that would benefit us less and would benefit the mafia more (since we would lose one turn to get a good information) The person (of there is any) who investigated satoshi is the one who received more information

I would vote for A since that is the question that wouldn't give information to the mafia but would benefit us a lot Each of us has to discover what kind of detective we are, most likely you investigated someone and you got inocent or mafia, but without knowing what are you, you can't simply say person X is mafia, let's kill them. The problem is that there is the randome detective you can only know if you investigated someone who is dead and even then it's hard to tell. To eliminate someone is hard right now, only in some nights we could be sure I will abstain Is there still the rule that we can't abstain 2 days in a row?

Lets do this

Blaziken, - torchic as Starter, that is your only option Haxorus, - you have a 1 in 18 chance to get axew from an event Krookodile, - as stated above, tanzan cove Venasaur, - only after the last gym (currently available) if you renovate azure island Glaceon, - eevee before Serra (I think it's the 6th gym) and you can get glaceon after the 7th gym and Dusknoir, right before shade I would recommend to get some of them from trades, because one will be only after you finish the current game and another you only have a 1 in 18 chance to get As stated above you should consider adding Pokémon for rotation, also if you want you can always use sandbox to add the Pokémon you want right after you select your starter.

Elanir isn't the one, I am 90% sure

You have to get a Meowth, even if technically meowth didnt belong to jessie or james

I know that elanir isn't Julia, no matter my role... About greninja is what he said, greninja visited quinnox on the tragic night of explosions. Since heather is dead, greninja is either Julia or Victoria

I don't know anything about you visiting me, but I know you visiting someone, and there are only 2 options for your identity, one of them is Julia

I know for certain that elanir isnt, but I suspect Greninja, he is one of 2 roles, I put my money that greninja is julia

I think its safe to assume that damsel and pdart are inocent, that leaves my suspicion on a few characters I would think its greninja

Eliminate - FairFamily

You are right. In a normal mafia game of around 20 people would have 4-5 criminals, the same number of cops and the rest town people (and sometimes special roles) that way it wouldn't work till pretty late game, where it might have been too late