Ice Cream Sand Witch

Chess, maybe? I'm pretty fond of Life though. Catan is amusing too... this is a hard question 

How mean-spirited of you... It's like asking a parent to pick their favorite child.

I've played Eldritch Horror some 30 to 40 times over the past year, but Patchwork is quickly rising through the ranks and is an amazing game to introduce people to the hobby. But then there are the classics like Twilight Struggle and Made Knight that I have played for multiple years on end without getting tired of. Oh and what about Ultimate Werewolf (read: Mafia) that I played monthly for the past 5 or so years...

Alas tis too hard to choose.