-
Posts
1329 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Reborn Development Blog
Rejuvenation Development Blog
Desolation Dev Blog
Everything posted by Alaris
-
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
that's too bad... I still think we should lynch bok -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
Yup perhaps I didn't explain myself clearly. With "ww-silver knight" I meant the inability of a ww-apprentice to become a ww-silver knight. First, because they would've chosen to become a Vampire Hunter, otherwise it's like throwing this role to the trash. Second, your dismissal of the most straightforward theory (i.e., the apprentice having chosen to become a VH, regardless if they're town or ww), seems an attempt to confuse the town. Imo things are like this: - Apprentice is not a Vampire. - Apprentice chose to become a Vampire Hunter. -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
So this particular comment caught my eye. I think this ww-silver knight theory, put forward by Ali, is rather far-fetched and heavily unlikely. Bringing it up as a theory is imo an acceptable contribution, but defending it here as the most likely option as Bok did seems too scummy for me. This, added to the vote on Nick based on rather flimsy arguments (he voted baz and actually alerted that some people were indirectly pushing for the lynch), makes Bok seem very suspicious to me. [Eliminate] Bok Also this sudden BW on Yahen is sketchy -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
So Baz wasn't lying after all. I still don't understand why the vamps would kill a role that has no detrimental effect on them. I mean, I guess it's because town will be decimated more quickly if the two factions are alive, but still, the death of a couple of werewolves wouldn't affect that... I feel it has been too early in the game. ...oooor the vamps really thought Baz was another vampire. But that was certainly rather unlikely because Baz claimed Vampire Hunter first, so he definitely didn't want to be visited by vampires. There will be two kills next night, so I wouldn't skip the lynch today. I don't have any lead though. -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
ok I get where you're going so options 4 and 5 are indeed less likely --- 1. You could still visit other vamps, and also you'd make sure a vamp kill is not "wasted" on you. 2. Okay 3. Okay 4. Okay 5. Okay But this doesn't convince me tbh -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
...uh care to elaborate? -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
You got it wrong. They don't share chats in any of the 5 possible scenarios. The one in which they shared a chat was removed for obvious reasons (a werewolf-assassin would never attempt a kill on a werewolf-vamp slayer). Thus the 5 possible scenarios are all equally likely. -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
I completely advise against this. If Baz is not the Silver Knight, the real one should NOT counterclaim. That would be wasting the role. So you are basing your whole reasoning on 1/5 possibility?? -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
To help nano? On what? If: 1) Nano was town. The Vamp Hunter would not claim, especially with an Assassin around. 2) Nano was wolf. If the Vamp Hunter were a wolf too, he would've told him. If the Vamp Hunter was town, they would not claim with the Assassin around. 3) Nano was a vamp. Same, the Vamp Hunter would simply not claim and surely, not to "help" nano. Thus I don't follow your reasoning. The possibilities are: 1) nano town, vamp hunter town 2) nano town, vamp hunter wolf 3) nano wolf, vamp hunter town 4) nano vamp, vamp hunter town 5) nano vamp, vamp hunter wolf --- And I insist, I'd like to know why Bazaro called the Silver Knight 'Werewolf Hunter'... it seems to me that he was just grasping at straws and didn't even bother to check how the other role was named. -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
This part is also false: - A Vampire Hunter is indeed immune to Vapire kills, very much like - A Silver Knight (funny how you haven't used the name yet) is immune to Werewolf kills - A Vampire Hunter is NOT immune to Werewolf kills and - A Silver Knight is NOT immune to Vampire kills -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
Because you could be a wolf claiming vamp slayer. Anyway, nano always shoots at will, so it's not weird he attacked the first person that claimed. -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
I'm not removing my vote on you. Nano died because he guessed wrong. Not because he attacked you. (ninja'd) -
[GAME END] Dark Ages 2(Mafia Game)
Alaris replied to sailboat's topic in Reborn Mafia Club's General Mafia
I had totally forgotten about this xD [Eliminate] Bazaro I think it's clear, as has been said... - Nano would not attack a Vampire Slayer being a Vampire. That would be even too kamikaze for him. And anyway, the post clearly states that Nano guessed wrong. - Therefore, Baz probably lied about being the vamp slayer. Also, it appears that cass was targeted by both factions last night. What a remarkable coincidence. Finally, I have no relevant info.