Mr. Knightly

@andracass Unfortunately no, wish I had. Not gonna lie, stupid as it sounds, I invested Dive then Venus, who both died. I have no more info then you guys. I think Amber is a good target for today, but if you rather we can hang Cataline and I will invest him (despite the fact that I will be dead).

@Cataline @Captain Breakfast @Caimie @Psychic Sheep @andracass @LykosHand @Bok Choi Alright I didn't want to do this but better I die at night then another townie. I am the cop guys. idk why every one is so quiet and just going with the flow but I bet at least one of the people who voted me is mafia. If you don't believe me you will when I turn up dead tomorrow. [Unvote] Cataline [Eliminate] Digital Amber

@LykosHand Not a-hundred percent sure what you want me to say at this point. I have been doing my best given the limited information, and contributing a fair amount. I guess the main thing I can say is why did I save Dive first day, only to kill him at night? And why did I intentionally stop a three way lynch? If I were mafia I would definitively not have done that. As for voting L'Belle he seemed really suspicious. Plus, I waited for him to make a good defense and he never did. More then that why would I be constantly calling for more activity if I was mafia. I made a poor read I admit it, but I only made one and I protected a townie day 1. smh I am not mafia I hope you can believe me.

Alright guys I am back, sorry I was late had stuff to take care of. It is funny that you placed a vote on me @DigitalAmber because I was considering placing one on you. It has been very hard to read anyone this game due to the lack of talking and as you said pressure votes appear to have no effect. However I am not one to ignore a pressure vote. Despite making poor reads, I believe I have done my best given the circumstances. Now please bear with me as I present my ideas. Alright here is my list of players from towniest to scumiest Towny Bok. I know this seems weird, but he seems legit to me. He has been making points that make logical sense and appears to be trying to help town. Less towny Lykos. I feel like he should be posting more, although this is typical of his play style. I couldn't say for sure. Cass. Seems pretty towny but I would have expected more interaction from her. Plus the way she just said she hoped we were right about L'Belle without adding anything seems kinda like mafia trying to blend. idk these players need to talk more. Bean, Captain Breakfast, and Caimie. Scumier Digital amber. idk I would expect more posts from him, plus he just appears to be throwing suspicion around without actually blaming anyone. He appears to be trying to get others to do the blaming for him. Plus he suspects me over Bok which seems very strange. Not to mention when Zero was playing he seemed very suspicious. Scumiest Cataline I mean really she just keeps yelling about how little she is doing without doing anything. For now consider this a pressure vote. [Eliminate] Cataline This list is obviously subject to change, and please tell me if I overlooked something. I am tired and probably not thinking to straight. Your thoughts please guys. @Cataline @Captain Breakfast @Caimie @Psychic Sheep @andracass @LykosHand @Bok Choi

@LykosHand @Venus @andracass Why are you so quiet this game? I would really appreciate your inputs on all the players. I know there is not much info, but you must suspect someone maybe only slightly, but the way to get more info is by talking yourselves and pressure voting those you find suspicious.

@Cataline The only reason you were top was because I thought Venus had claimed the cop and had invested you, however upon further reflection it may have just been a pressure vote. I just really don't know what to do about Venus because he says so little. And a every little thought counts guys so keep em coming.

@andracass Thanks for the clarification. I understand the rationale more now that you have made that clarification, although personally I wouldn't expect Dive to use the same strategy in a row like that. The only reason I voted Cataline is that Venus soft-claimed cop (which is something I am given to believe he does often). Personally I didn't really suspect her till he did that, and so far no one has done anything to counter him, though I just had a thought. @Venus Are you claiming cop or was that just a pressure vote to make Cat talk? Till we get some clarification, [Unvote] Cataline [Eliminate] L'Belle I urge you @LykosHand to be careful of what might just be a pressure vote. Also Cass what are you're thoughts on the players so far?

@Cataline idk how you could know if you got invested or not that doesn't really make any sense. Currently the only real reason anyone has voted you is because Venus has soft-claimed the cop which if you turn out town we can hang him tomorrow. However in case he is a mafia would mind telling us your current reads on people?

@Venus So you are the cop huh? I suggest you invest L'Belle tonight at that point. Remember guys just cause we know who the cop is doesn't mean we shouldn't continue to search for more mafia. [Eliminate] Cataline I would like to see what other players think of people but this is my list of suspicious players. Top is obviously Cataline. Second is L'Belle. L'Belle says that they want to contribute, but all they have said to day is why the bean votes. And why does he want to protect Bean in the first place? I think Bean might be mafia as well (bean wouldn't have to change his style at all and he could survive every day and no one would notice. I really only think this though, because L'Belle appears to be protecting him). More than that he reacts violently to Dive's reasonable suspicion of him, and leaves his vote on Dive creating a bw on what was just another friendly townie. Second is Andracass who we all know is analytical, but appears to be throwing Day 1 to the wind and not even trying to read people. She continues to say little and powers L'Belle's bw with very flimsy reasoning of "Dive voting L'Belle at the very beginning reminds me far too much of what happened last game with me, and I remember how that one turned out. There's almost literally no reason to be suspecting anyone when nothing's happened (hence L'Belle's question), and the fact that Dive is maintaining his vote after L'Belle tries to defend himself is really rubbing me the wrong way." Not really the kind of solid rational we have come to expect from her. And Thirdly Zeropassion and Captain Breakfast. Kinda a tie about whom I suspect more atm. Zeropassion votes people with very little reason and just appears to go with the flow which is much like what he did in a previous game where he was mafia. And Captain Breakfast who does basically the same thing as Zeropassion only with even less conviction. Less suspicous Bok choy. Despite causing a townie to be lynched his reasoning was pretty good, and he may very well not have noticed the bw that formed, and he is trying to be helpful. Venus. He appears to be claiming Cop (on day 2) which would be a very silly thing to do if he was mafia. This list is of course subject to change, but being day 2 it is hard to get a read on anyone especially given how little has been said. We really need to talk more guys. Being quiet only helps the mafia.

Don't just kill Dive, L'belle, and Bean all on the first day guys! Seriously [Unvote] L'Belle [Eliminate] Bean

@Captain Breakfast Pretty much except, with my vote there are two on one person and one on two others. When L'Belle voted Dive they made a triple tie and if the day ends like that all three are jailed/lynched.

@Captain Breakfast Oof thanks, don't know how I missed that . I don't think there is much time left so we need to decide if we want to lynch bean or L'Belle. At this point I don't want to risk a triple lynch.

I'll join.

Maybe that's true Bok, but right now I am with DIve. Ordinarily I would vote Bean because they are generally not as helpful as L'Belle, but by voting Dive, L'Belle puts three possible townies in danger. This could be clumsy mafia, or third party, but for now, [Eliminate] L'Belle

So little has happened smh. Hard to work on so little info, but eventually everyone will have to meet the post requirements right? I am curious @Filthy Casual what happens in the case of a tie? At this point we probably don't want to cause a possible double lynch.

Why am I always Third Party, I stink at third party, I wanna be a good boi! Btw Alaris was not my target

@Alaris Yes having the cop check him would be nice, and you (if you don't have a better target) can watch Roswell so you know who the cop is and we don't lynch them. Furthermore you can keep tabs on them while the doc gets you.

I will join your Filthy game

@NickCrash Why am I not surprised.

GG guys, guess the warden is out'a a job cause all his prisoners are dead.

@Alaris Ah, I see it makes sense now. It did seem strange to be so revealing as mafia I guess I should have guessed it was a trap, very clever. To those who might still suspect Alaris there's no reason he would need to buss his team-mate and reveal himself by claiming a role he is not. [Unvote] Alaris [Eliminate] Lia My current suspects are Lia (obviously), L'belle (not really adding anything and voting Filthy), Caimie (adding nothing to the discussion and voting Lia to throw suspicion away from her), and maybe Roswell? Your thoughts? Sorry I bandwagoned on you

@Roswell I suppose I understand your suspicion, but I wouldn't call this flimsy reasons. So far the people who have done the most to look for mafia are you, me, Lia, and Nicki (this is upsetting in it's own right, but that's another matter). We all know Alaris is intelligent and good at scum-hunting, but he has yet to do anything but post filler posts. As so many people have said finding mafia is in part based on a players behavior and for a guy who won an award for being tactical I think his lack of talking (even after my pressure vote) is suspicious. @purplecicada This can't be the case as he was talking Yesterday. His voting without reason while it may be in character with him is frustrating and makes me suspicious of him. @Captain Breakfast Even if you don't know who to suspect you can still present your ideas and tell us who you think is good or evil. @Walpurgis @Jason Grace Thoughts on Alaris?

Okay I don't know why Venus suddenly voted Dive apparently without reading what he said (Venus hotbirb?), and Alaris just voted Filthy and has been doing way to little talking. Every time I have played with him he has said more and been more active. He seems really off right now. Before now he said that he had never been mafia. Statistically he has to be mafia eventually. Perhaps he is mafia and this would explain his sudden change in behavior. It was also strange the way he just followed my vote on Archeric without giving his own reasons, which is what he generally does. Till a better suspect shows up. [Eliminate] Alaris

For that reason I am also gonna put Caimie, bok, and Venus on my suspect list (though less so Venus because this appears to be how he plays, frustrating as it is).

That would make things easier. The last game I was in with a silencer the person who was silenced got a fake warning so you didn't know who was actually silenced, unless only one person didn't talk.