Yahy, would you rather I have outed myself Day 1 and claimed Ame was Usamo or claimed [redacted for they have still yet to publically claim it] was your precious Fuyuhiko or however it’s spelled? I would have been confirmed night kill or perhaps you would, depending on the town’s actions and which roles are mafia. Knowing a person’s role doesn’t tell you their alignment, it would have benefited the mafia more then the town at that point if I claimed. For example, if I found Nagito and revealed him, a currently alive player would be dead. I’m not the best at subtly roleclaiming.
I didn’t mean to try to throw suspicion on Caimie, I’m just saying that she has an equal chance to be blackened as you do or Evi does, or Ali, or Lykos, or Newt. At the start of the game she had a 4/18~ chance of being blackened.
As this is mafia, we must face the grim idea that people will lie. It’s simply how the game works.