Jump to content

Alistair

Veterans
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2289

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    12

 Content Type 

Profiles

Forums

Events

Reborn Development Blog

Rejuvenation Development Blog

Desolation Dev Blog

Everything posted by Alistair

  1. Alistair
    The OP describes Silver Knight as "non-werewolf exclusive" so I'm not sure a werewolf Apprentice could even elect to become Silver Knight at all. It's unclear whether the "non-werewolf exclusive" part applies only to the initial distribution of roles or to all game mechanics as well.
  2. Alistair
    @Jelly I'm interested in your opinion of Yahen, pls elaborate
  3. Alistair
    No certainty here but I'm inclined to believe the Apprentice being nowhere to be found is just flavor text. That doesn't necessarily mean the Apprentice is absent from the game. @sailboat confirmation pls? And sure, several of us have played that old game and the thread is still accessible to all, so I don't see why reading it would be considered cheating. Have fun!
  4. Alistair
    There's Nothing that indicates a roleblocking effect would impact the Apprentice's ability to inherit another role, especially since the Apprentice's power translates into a choice they make at the beginning of the game, rather than a night action. Because of this, I believe the Apprentice really did choose to inherit Vampire Slayer instead of Silver Knight. Since Vampire Slayer is a pointless (harmful, even) role for a vampire, I think it's safe to assume the Apprentice isn't a vampire. That leaves us with two options. The Apprentice is a werewolf, and picked the only option that made sense for them. The Apprentice is town, and chose to fight vampires. That's a logical choice and the one I would make since vampires can kill someone every night, as opposed to werewolves who come out of the woods every other night. Both options are equally possible. In a sense, whether the Vampire Slayer is town or wolf matters little to us as townies, since they'll be equally capable of slaying vampires in both cases. On an unrelated note, PSA: if an exposed vampire or an exposed werewolf offers to compromise with the town in order to take down the other mafia faction, don't trust them. Allowing werewolves to live because we perceived them to be a lesser threat cost us the game during the previous DAM.
  5. Alistair
    wew Baz was apparently inno what a surprise @Jason Grace sorry for the ping but I miss your analytic prowess I have townreads on Bok, Kiet, Nick and Yahen so far. Maybe Drago too. Most of the others seem to just be going with the flow without contributing much. Also hi Bean how u
  6. Alistair
    I'm good, work isn't fun but I've had worse Mondays. Why are you defending Lykos? Any reason in particular? Voting for themselves is something people do sometimes, but I really don't think it's a good idea because it basically doesn't help at all. It's just the go-to vote when you don't know what else to do, I guess.
  7. Alistair
    last time I voted Nicki, people thought that made me sus how are you today, my friendly peepos?
  8. Alistair
    You guys sure have posted a lot in only 24h, yikes. That was verging to TL;DR territory. That said, today's posts were kinda fun to read. Baz's roleclaim seemed to be obvious bluff to me but w/e, at least we know he was lying now since Nano killed himself trying to guess his role (gg). I don't really believe Baz to be maf. Looks more like a townie trying his luck to a funky strategy imo. Try not to lynch him, guys. He's definitely interesting to keep around. [Eliminate] Lykos I like you man but you bw'd poor Baz a bit too hastily. Other people did, but most of them were also very active throughout the day phase and actively contributing to the discussion, so they seem less suspicious to me.
  9. Alistair
    that's like super ironic especially considering the survivalist has 2 lives come to think of it, how did she manage to die N0? did 2 killing roles just decide to N0 her? what are the odds also flavor text with absence of blood is interesting
  10. Alistair
    and now we've come full circle discord name = forum name
  11. Alistair
    I hope you guys know what you're doing, because otherwise this day phase was a huge missed opportunity
  12. Alistair
    [Unvote] Jace [Eliminate] Newt @ people who may have the power to change things today, I think the situation's worth a gamble provided you aren't afk ofc
  13. Alistair
    pls Drago, we both know it's not the case or, if you really believe Newt is bluffing, then you must believe that I'm white since he wants to eliminate me? except you don't. also Kiet said basically the same thing as me about Newt risking death, and strangely enough I don't see anyone pointing that out thanks for your implied colorclaim tho In case any gun holders wonder who they should target, so far we have: - White: Lía, Newt, Kiet, Drago - Black: Nicki, Jace - Uncertain: everyone else
  14. Alistair
    Newt what are you doing? You do know Nano gave black piece(s) guns before dying, right? You just claimed one of the most important roles and told the blacks "henlo pls shoot me." Now we basically have to pray that you don't die within the next few hours. I don't get why everyone is implicitly or explicitly colorclaiming already. Black isn't in position to do that for obvious reasons, and White doesn't yet have enough of a lead to make up for a couple guns going off today. This is borderline gamethrowing. [Eliminate] Jace Stormkirk Placeholder vote, may change it later depending on what does or doesn't happen.
  15. Alistair
    Poll #10: Candy https://docs.google.com/forms/d/12YBITj0J-xV_2a5wSYnrcW9QaGSx0uyzACTsO2zisec/edit
  16. Alistair
    vote mypet instead
  17. Alistair
    guys idk why but I think Lía is white
  18. Alistair
    unpack me mommy
  19. Alistair
    Unfortunately other than Amine and Nano's slip-ups (?) there's not that much to analyze rip Nicki's acting kinda shady I guess but this isn't a standard mafia game with an informed minority and an uninformed majority, so acting shady isn't really a reason to kill someone off here. I guess my vote stays for now unless Amine blesses me with max luck for my next FEH pulls
  20. Alistair
    [Eliminate] Nanomine What do you mean only one at a time Ok I guess [Eliminate] Amine
  21. Alistair
    Soooo... if I followed everything, the white side is now essentially just missing 1 pawn, and the black side is missing 2. Cool cool. Any cop reports?
  22. Alistair
    I mean, unless you're maf or another special role with private chats you normally don't have a space to safely discuss things with your faction Lía wants maf confirmed
  23. Alistair
  24. Alistair
    Nicki hitting us with the bluffaroo Let's see... the least risky move is probably to eliminate the inactive person who's most likely going to end up being dead weight anyway @Martin994CZ speak now or yeetus forever [Eliminate] Martin
  25. Alistair
    ^
×
×
  • Create New...