Jump to content

CURIE

Veterans
  • Posts

    1541
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

CURIE last won the day on September 25 2023

CURIE had the most liked content!

Reputation

137 Benefactor

8 Followers

About CURIE

  • Birthday 07/12/1995

Recent Profile Visitors

238437 profile views

Single Status Update

See all updates by CURIE

  1. My thoughts on the new Death Note manga oneshot (spoiler safe)

     

     

     

     

     

    First of all I should mention how I've seen a lot of people say it's bad because "it doesn't have the epic back-and-forth cat-and-mouse game like the original".  If you were expecting or hoping for something like that from a oneshot issue, you were being silly.  I thought it was good for what it was, aside from two big missteps.

     

    Spoiler

    The first (and lesser) problem is that Near basically does nothing.  That'd be fine, if he was just there for two or three pages where he decides he has no way of catching the new main character and leaves.  But no, he and his officer buddies take up exactly 20 pages (I counted) which is almost a quarter of the whole issue.  They could have either cut out most of that and focused on the main character more, or invested more into Near's involvement and had it lead up to something more than "I give up lol".

     

    Even then I really liked the manga overall until the end.  The ending is the REAL problem.  It kinda spits in the face of the whole series: the Death Gods literally make up a new rule at the very last second and don't tell the main character about it, so he dies even though he did everything right.  What's worse is that there's some bad design in the manga itself: it seems to show that the rule was changed WHILE the guy still had the Death Note and was still never told about it, which actually breaks an existing rule of the Death Gods being up front about their own rules.  It's only after going back and re-reading the page carefully that you realized they covered their bases in saying Ryuk didn't change the rule until after the kid gave it up.  Even still, it's dumb and only exists to reach the pre-decided endpoint of "the main character always dies".  At least almost everyone but him has a happy ending I guess?

     

    Other than those two things I really liked it.  I would like to see another oneshot after this, because it leaves the world in an... interesting geopolitical state.

    1. CURIE

      CURIE

      Oh right, I should also mention there was another oneshot made back in 2008.  It was lame and dumb, this new one's much better.

×
×
  • Create New...