Newt

@Venus Although I do not know, I'm pretty sure hes is talking about the role Hooligan, and not about himself. And for the way he said, it seems he is not the Hooligan role, and he thinks that this role may be of the mafia

Well, you actually almost roleclaimed in that sentence (Thats why I said I kinda knew what your role was): But because of that, Alistar is not the Quack Doctor and neither are you, so we can exclude those two theories. But well, not everything was in vain because now I have a list of townies. Also, weak doctor, doctor turk and heroic doctor, if you are alive you should protect Venus every night. (Not you, Paul, because if you do so, he'll cannot heal Jace) List of townies: Dark Rogue (myself :P) Jace Alistair (maybe) Venus Also, sorry Venus. I didn't mean to make you roleclaim. ;-; (it seems I'm the noob screwing everything, so I guess I'll stop making those theories, as its helping more the mafia than us)

Ok. I'll show y'all what I think. There are four hypotheses. I'll ask for everyone help to decide which one is right. 1) Paul is not the ICU Doctor. He is actually a member of the mafia. If that's right, Eviora is also lying. The true ICU Doctor was Dive, and before dying he protect Alistair. After Alistair told us that he had been blocked (we can say that he is not lying because venus visited him and didn't succeed), Paul claimed he was the ICU, and that he was the one who protected Alistair. He could do that because if he was part of the mafia, he would know that the nurse blocked Jace. If that's correct, then Paul and Eviora are mafia, Jace is townie and there is a chance that Venus is the quack doctor. (I think this theory is the less likely to be true) 2) Alistair is the Quack Doctor. No one was poisoned because he was blocked. If this one is correct, then Paul, Venus and Jace are townies, while Alistair is mafia. (I actually bet in this one) 3) Venus is the Quack Doctor. He tried to poison alistair but he was protected by the ICU. Therefore Venus is mafia and Alistair is townie. (I don't have any solid proof, but I think this one is incorrect because I think Venus... has another specific role.. but just my opinion tho, could be right) 4) The Pharmacist was the one poisoned and he self-healed. (I hope its not this one, or everything I did was in vain) Please, tell me your opinions.

The ECT doctor killed one (Hooligan) and the mafia killed the other (Amine) Also Alistair, do not worry, I pretend to leash the information soon. I just need to do some readjustments in my theory so it'll not have flaws. But on the other hand, I would have to roleclaim so it can make sense for everyone. Do you guys think I should do that?

I might have some information that may lead us to one of the mafia members, and depending on Venus response, I'll have a list of some people who I am certain to be townies. Therefore, I'll wait some time before leashing what I have. I know what I just said may lead to me being targeted, thus I would like to ask @Paul25 for protection. Also, if the weak doctor or doctor turk is alive, you should protect Paul. I know that the mafia will read this, but I think it will make things harder for them next night, as they'll don't know who to killl.

So, me and you were blocked. I think I got blocked by the angry nurse and you by the ICU, as you solicited protection.

So we lost two townies T.T R.I.P Hooligan and Amine. Also, Jace seems to be poisoned. Let's hope that the pharmacist wasn't any of the dead. @Venus I have a question for you. At N0, were you able to do your night action successfully? Or did something happen? (Do not worry, I'm not suspecting you, but depending on your answer, and if my logic is correct, I might know who is one of the mafia members) Also, who got blocked tonight?

Well, if everyones just vote for themselves it just won't do any good, and as Eviora said, we probably won't be able to gather 9 votes to another person this later in the day, so [Eliminate] No one Guess we are back to zero T.T

Yeah, it was my bad. T.T [Eliminate] Paul (sorry again)

Oh, you're right. My bad, I didn't see this post. So everyone posted at least once.. Is no one poisoned?!

Hey guys, I'm going to change my vote: [Eliminate] EndearingCharacterTrait Reason: He is the only one that didn't post once, so that means he is either the poisoned one or the Quack Doctor. As I mentioned earlier, the reason no one has been poisoned yet could be that the quack doctor was afk, and he was last seen monday. If he is poisoned, he was going to die this night and the result would be the same as if we lynched him, meaning that there is no chance of losing 3 town members at once. I hope I explained myself well, and I want your opinions on this.

Or the Quack Doctor was afk and didn't do their night actions. (I can see that happening) Well, as I said I would follow your decision, I'll [Eliminate] Paul25 (sorry if you're not mafia T.T)

Oooo my name is in there! I'm in

Assuming that Dive wasn't the Pharmacist...

Also, I'm sorry for the mistakes I made and I'll probably make, I'm just trying to get some info, and, well, my role is not that useful for that.

Would the person that had been poisoned know? If not, that would be a problem. I know. It just seemed weird, but ok, as I said your behavior was not wrong, just.. weird Now there is something intriguing me. The note that Dive had when he died, did Anti_Hero put it ramdomly or it has a meaning and its a clue?

You indeed have a point. So I'll give my opinion about someone that seems suspicious. Venus. As I already mentioned, he was the first to abstain (not that it really matters) and the he tried to find something in what I have said to accuse me. I know that this is what we are supposed to do, but that accusation was all of sudden, and for me, it was a bit strange the way he did it. I'll wait for your opinions to cast my vote.

Well, the first one that decided not to lynch was Venus, but honestly, I still feel that no lynch is the best option, because if we choose the wrong person (chances are 75%), we'll be at disadvantage. And there is also the chance of lynching someone really important, like the Psychiatrist or the Weak Doctor. Even so, I'll follow your leads if you decide to lynch someone.

But if we lynch the wrong person (that is the most likely thing to happen) the mafia will have an even better advantage over us. (This is my opinion, as this is the first time I play this type of game, im not experienced enough to say something tbh).

Well, just by saying that you'll probably end up being targeted, so I think you should share the information you have, as we do not have any useful info to find the mafia yet.

I assumed that because from what it seems, the only way to get ??? Is by the janitor killing someone, as Anti answered me that when the amnesiac dies, it appears that they were third party.

So he was indeed killed by the janitor. Yes, he could still be the amnesiac, but I think thats a low chance, thus the amnesiac is probably alive. Well, as this is the first day and we don't have any good leads, I'll [Eliminate] No one (I'll change my vote if some worthy info comes up).

@Anti_Hero, if he was the amnesiac his alignment would also appear as "???", right?

Well, there are three options: 1) Dive was the Amnesiac, and since he doesn't have an alignment, it couldn't be revealed; 2) Dive got killed by the janitor; 3) Dive was the amnesiac AND got killed by the janitor. (Most unlikely)

Actually, I think that Dive was the Amnesiac. Thus, his alignment wasn't revealed because he didn't have one.