Eviora

Are you sure you know that? What if on N2 (I think xD) the mafia killed Hypurr and the vigilante killed Junko disguised as Hiro? Then there would be no inconsistency with you believing you're Sayaka, Lia being Byakuya, and the mafia having killed Dive, the real Sayaka.

@NickCrash So, to make sure we're on the same page, your advice for the vigilante is, if they didn't kill Dive, they should kill you during the next night phase?

@L'Belle Let's settle this. If someone tries to block a player who has no night action, do you notify them that someone attempted to roleblock them?

Well, this is really getting quite heated! All this strife seems to have started from a simple statement on Nick's part that he hadn't been roleblocked on N2... or whatever night that was. Nick, might I ask how you know you weren't roleblocked?

@NickCrash Would you mind humoring me a bit? You said Paul is one of your scumreads, so join us in voting for him. If you don't, and if Corso gets lynched then flips town, my suspicion of you will grow dramatically. [Eliminate] Paul25

Oh, by the way, the list at the bottom is just something I copied to remind myself of who was left and forgot to remove. xD

Okay, I'll make a list. I'll start with people I most think are town and end with people I most think are mafia. Towniest Eviora - No surprises here. I know I'm town. Andracass - Uncontested Toko roleclaim and confirmed town by Walpurgis, who was revealed to be Byakuya. Walpurgis - Was revealed as Byakuya and then vouched for Andracass, suggesting they knew their role believed themselves to be Sayaka. I don't think Junko would have known which role she was impersonating - am I wrong about that? Lykoshand - Has been active and made the same decisions I have throughout the game. I see no evidence suggesting he's mafia. NickCrash - General townread, but I can't help but be suspicious. You've fooled me before. Your arguments seem strongly town - so strongly it's almost suspicious. I may just be paranoid in this regard. However, without definitive evidence I can't dismiss the possibility that you're just playing really well. Psychic Bean Sheep - I'm going to be honest. I have no idea how to read this guy. His actions in these games seem incredibly whimsical to me. He could easily be on either side. Bok Choi and Caimie - They both defended Nicky, which works against them. Other than that, I guess I haven't read any strong vibes from them. It may help to review older posts. Corso - My reasoning is (ironically) basically the same as Paul's here. He also defended Nicky and has been targeting players I'm inclined to trust. Paul25 - No surprises here, either. He changed his vote from Nicky to Knightly near the end of the voting period. If one more person had joined him, Nicky would have been saved. Scummiest Overall, I can't say I'm really satisfied with how reliant my reads are on how people reacted to Nicky. I don't feel there's all that much information to work with, though. 2. Psychic Bean Sheep 3. Corso 4. Lykoshand 5. Purplecicada - Monokuma 6. Andracass 7. Jace Stormkirk - Alter Ego 8. Alistair - Aoi Asahina 9. Caimie 10. Eviora 11. Bok Choi 12. NickCrash 13. Mr. Knightly - Chihiro Fujisaki 14. Paul25 15. Walpurgis

We're going to try something new today! This game, you will be judged by Pickle Satan! That's right - I volunteer as tribute juror!

Oh, well, okay. I'm not really sold on Candy and I need to vote for someone, so I'll just waste my vote like this. [Eliminate] Jace Stormkirk

I did ask if anyone else wanted to claim Toko. That wasn't too long ago, so it's possible not everyone has seen it yet.

For one, Byakuya is town, and I'd like to figure out who my allies are. Also, if Byakuya were to confirm they're talking to Toko, then I would have concrete reason to believe Andra's claim.

I assume that by "the loudmouth" you mean Toko. Before, I mentioned Andracass must be either Kyoko, Toko, Junko, or Celeste. Since half those roles are mafia, I'm trying to determine which it is, and she just practically roleclaimed Toko without me asking. Obviously, I put two and two together.

That's unfortunate. By saying you're talking to Byakuya privately, you're basically roleclaiming Toko. Does anyone else contest that roleclaim?

You'll ask Byakuya? How are you going to do that?

@andracass I noticed you didn't answer my question. Also, what made you think Nicki is Monokuma? I also recall you later decided to trust her about being Mondo, which she wasn't. The fact that you bring up your previous stance as a sort of "told ya so" after making that mistake seems incredibly strange to me. Also, guys, I don't understand the bandwagon on Candy. Please explain why you feel she's mafia.

@NickCrash It seems to me that your logic is flawed on both of those matters. For one, I see nothing in Junko's role description that requires her to maintain a single costume until that player dies. As far as I can tell, she can switch every night as she pleases. As for Sakura, if Junko did impersonate her, the mafia would indeed know her role, but I don't think Sakura is a particularly high value target. The mafia would probably want to kill someone more dangerous than her. After all, Sakura's role is basically to lay down her own life for someone more valuable to the town.

@NickCrash Maybe I'm missing something... what makes you say we'll know about Sakura by the next day for sure?

Also, if someone happens to be Sakura, you should *absolutely* roleclaim. It's possible our dead Sakura is actually Junko.

Very interesting, @andracass. You visited Byakuya last night. That means you have a role capable of visiting. At this point, that means you can only be Kyoko, Toko, Junko, or Celeste. I wonder what your thoughts are about that. By the way, since you visited Byakuya, why don't you tell us who they are?

By the way, according to L'Belle's previous post, I believe Alter Ego is considered to have a night action, so there's one more than you think.

@andracass Do note you're assuming Nicki is Mondo. I believe we'll find out soon whether that's true. If she isn't, the problem disappears.

@Mr. Knightly I think you just want to win the vote. =p Also, @andracass, what leads you to say that?

No, I don't think that reason is sufficient at all. We can break the outcomes into two cases: 1. Suppose you choose your kills well. That would make us less likely to lynch you and more urgent that the mafia do so. 2. Suppose you choose your kills poorly. In that case, it's still in our favor to lynch you even if you are Mondo. In short, the only way the mafia would let you live is if you were actively hindering us.

I have mixed feelings about Nicki's claim. On one hand, vigilante is a valuable role I would rather not lose. On the other hand, Nicki is fully aware of that, and she's also aware that even if she's lying, for the same reason, the real Mondo can't contradict her. Even if Nicki is Mondo and we don't lynch her, she'll have a huge target on her head. So in the event that we unvote her and she somehow survives the night without Sakura's protection, I'd say that would again suggest she's mafia. Therefore, given the circumstances, I intend to stick with my current vote. This roleclaim just seems a little bit too convenient.

Normally, it would make sense not to shoot on the first night, but we had a day phase before that. It offered some opportunity to learn about others. Still, not shooting is an acceptable strategy. Can you confirm that's what you did? I noticed you've been answering questions with questions or hypotheticals.