Okay, I am months late to this parade. But I am fine with that because I am terrible at finding places to speak. Okay, so going back to the Original poster of the thread Cyphre. I can somewhat side with three of his theories #2, #3, and #6. For instance we know she knows about the Archetype and it's powers, leaving the main people who would know or have being major categories. I'm excluding the theory of it being Anathea cause literally she doesn't have body and is inhabiting the soul stone (Unless the devs have some bodysnatching plans I don't think it's her). Then for the theory of it being the first human... that just feels kinda scattered little info (Could potentially be right, but not delving into it. ) So it's un likely. Nora Royer... I played WLL only once so I forget.
Now saying it's Erin... it would make sense as Madame X's first words to Maria(nette) in the prologue of the game is pretty much the same as what Erin says to Maria before she gets flung into the Unown dimension. And yeah, presumably the time in the Unown dimension screws with you in several ways (Not aging is included)... Erin hating Indriad(vitus)... doesn't really link up with Madame X, we have no info of her even being connected to Vitus unless your including the idea that Vitus=Yveltal. and even if you try to use that weird Yveltal cocoon in that Xen base in Sheridan Swamplands, as saying Team Xen is trying to destroy Yveltal, then what the heck is with the Vitus ghost possessing Angie, or even Wispy Tower and his connection with Geara. (Well... Wispy Tower may be an outlier since it did get destroyed.). And don't you dare forget is you do actually manage to beat Madame X on Blacksteeple she says "Father, I have lost...". not something I think I'd hear from the Father hating Erin that I learned about in V13. But also Personally I don't think it's Erin.
Now before we go too deep into the theories arguing that Madame X is Marianette or Melia. Let's go back to when we first are proven that Erin, Allen and Alice are all related to Maria and revealing that Melia should be Maria. Melia denies being Maria. But we do have some gap years between some events circulating around Maria(nette). With one gap arguing the direct ages between Melia and Marianette. Yes we don't know exactly how old Melia was when she met Venam (we can really assume she is around the same age.) But let's take a look at Zetta for a second we know that Zetta was created from Melia's DNA. That was because Melia was too young at the time of Madame X's plan. But would that mean She's young enough for her to be younger than Maria? Honestly we don't have exact ages, so I couldn't tell you. But if I'm considering Melia and Maria being two different people... We could potentially have Madame X.
First things first. With the idea that Maria(nette) is Madame X. We first have the connection of Anastasia and Nastasia being the one and the same. Maria being Anastasia's one friend as a child, cause Anastasia be very loyal to her. Mass producing Deoxys for her. Yes in that past time line where that dreaded Gardevoir is killed, last we assume of Anastasia is that she's somewhere in that underground area. Meaning she could have found and freed Maria. Now going on a tangent we know that Madame X's Armor doesn't really come off (From the Pyramid events I think it holds her back if anything), But I think it is actually keeping Madame X alive. Now we know that prior to having her four children Anathea had black hair, the Archetype gave her golden hair... Now what would happen if you were to drain the archetype from said person? If you said they would die you are correct... but I'm wondering if their hair would change color say... Black. Now if this is true, combine this with the idea that the armor is keeping Madame X alive, we have an idea that Madame X may have been a holder of the Archetype's power. But what happened to the Archetype power that was drained from Maria... well it took form as... well Melia. Which would mean that Madame X knows who has this special power and how it can be used. Also in a sense in this crazy theory, Melia is Madame X's child. Technically Erin's Niece.
On that note. I don't really know how to end this, thank you for coming to my Theory. and... disprove me at where you see. I want to help build an actual good theory.
One more attempt to figure out Madame X identity [Spoilers, obviously]
in Discussions
Posted
Okay, I am months late to this parade. But I am fine with that because I am terrible at finding places to speak. Okay, so going back to the Original poster of the thread Cyphre. I can somewhat side with three of his theories #2, #3, and #6. For instance we know she knows about the Archetype and it's powers, leaving the main people who would know or have being major categories. I'm excluding the theory of it being Anathea cause literally she doesn't have body and is inhabiting the soul stone (Unless the devs have some bodysnatching plans I don't think it's her). Then for the theory of it being the first human... that just feels kinda scattered little info (Could potentially be right, but not delving into it. ) So it's un likely. Nora Royer... I played WLL only once so I forget.
Now saying it's Erin... it would make sense as Madame X's first words to Maria(nette) in the prologue of the game is pretty much the same as what Erin says to Maria before she gets flung into the Unown dimension. And yeah, presumably the time in the Unown dimension screws with you in several ways (Not aging is included)... Erin hating Indriad(vitus)... doesn't really link up with Madame X, we have no info of her even being connected to Vitus unless your including the idea that Vitus=Yveltal. and even if you try to use that weird Yveltal cocoon in that Xen base in Sheridan Swamplands, as saying Team Xen is trying to destroy Yveltal, then what the heck is with the Vitus ghost possessing Angie, or even Wispy Tower and his connection with Geara. (Well... Wispy Tower may be an outlier since it did get destroyed.). And don't you dare forget is you do actually manage to beat Madame X on Blacksteeple she says "Father, I have lost...". not something I think I'd hear from the Father hating Erin that I learned about in V13. But also Personally I don't think it's Erin.
Now before we go too deep into the theories arguing that Madame X is Marianette or Melia. Let's go back to when we first are proven that Erin, Allen and Alice are all related to Maria and revealing that Melia should be Maria. Melia denies being Maria. But we do have some gap years between some events circulating around Maria(nette). With one gap arguing the direct ages between Melia and Marianette. Yes we don't know exactly how old Melia was when she met Venam (we can really assume she is around the same age.) But let's take a look at Zetta for a second we know that Zetta was created from Melia's DNA. That was because Melia was too young at the time of Madame X's plan. But would that mean She's young enough for her to be younger than Maria? Honestly we don't have exact ages, so I couldn't tell you. But if I'm considering Melia and Maria being two different people... We could potentially have Madame X.
First things first. With the idea that Maria(nette) is Madame X. We first have the connection of Anastasia and Nastasia being the one and the same. Maria being Anastasia's one friend as a child, cause Anastasia be very loyal to her. Mass producing Deoxys for her. Yes in that past time line where that dreaded Gardevoir is killed, last we assume of Anastasia is that she's somewhere in that underground area. Meaning she could have found and freed Maria. Now going on a tangent we know that Madame X's Armor doesn't really come off (From the Pyramid events I think it holds her back if anything), But I think it is actually keeping Madame X alive. Now we know that prior to having her four children Anathea had black hair, the Archetype gave her golden hair... Now what would happen if you were to drain the archetype from said person? If you said they would die you are correct... but I'm wondering if their hair would change color say... Black. Now if this is true, combine this with the idea that the armor is keeping Madame X alive, we have an idea that Madame X may have been a holder of the Archetype's power. But what happened to the Archetype power that was drained from Maria... well it took form as... well Melia. Which would mean that Madame X knows who has this special power and how it can be used. Also in a sense in this crazy theory, Melia is Madame X's child. Technically Erin's Niece.
On that note. I don't really know how to end this, thank you for coming to my Theory. and... disprove me at where you see. I want to help build an actual good theory.