[E16 SPOILERS] Anna and Noel Hypothesis

[Ice Cream Sand Witch 1650]

21 minutes ago, dragonza11 said:

 

I totally forgot about cal and blake

 

and are you sure about the shining armor, because mine had that

I checked RPG Maker before submitting that post and it wasn't mentioned. Shining armor was however mentioned in the E17 preview after defeating Adrienn and exiting the Coral gym, so maybe you're thinking of that. 

 

20 minutes ago, Wolfox Glace said:

I have a theory of my own on anna and noel.

 

I have stated this in the past and I stick with it. I believe Radomus Vanhanen is the father of Anna and her Brother. if that is correct perhaps radomus took anna and noel to a saver place

It's a popular theory. I can see why people believe it, but my one issue with it is Radomus sending them to the orphanage. Radomus doesn't seem like the type of person to do or believe something without first doing his research, and I think he'd be able to find out what Sigmund does. 

 

That being said, I can't really think of any other candidate for Anna and Noel's father besides Shade or just someone who actually is gone and thus won't appear in the game and will only be mentioned for lore/backstory, but I'm not confident the latter is the case.

[dragonza11 12]

4 minutes ago, Ice Cream Sand Witch said:

I checked RPG Maker before submitting that post and it wasn't mentioned. Shining armor was however mentioned in the E17 preview after defeating Adrienn and exiting the Coral gym, so maybe you're thinking of that. 

 

that is possible but i may have put it wrong, she says something like shiny armor strikes

here a screenshot:

[Ice Cream Sand Witch 1650]

Just now, dragonza11 said:

 

that is possible but i may have put it wrong, she says something like shiny armor strikes

here a screenshot:

 

  Hide contents

 

 

 

 

 

Oops, I must have missed that part because I was skimming.

[Wolfox 2093]

1 minute ago, Ice Cream Sand Witch said:

It's a popular theory. I can see why people believe it, but my one issue with it is Radomus sending them to the orphanage. Radomus doesn't seem like the type of person to do or believe something without first doing his research, and I think he'd be able to find out what Sigmund does. 

 

That being said, I can't really think of any other candidate for Anna and Noel's father besides Shade (who I've ruled out because in his TV interview he tells the player to deliver the girl who sees all from the flat-lined creep), or just someone who actually is gone and thus won't appear in the game and will only be mentioned for lore/backstory, but I'm confident the latter is the case.

I have a theory about that aswell. It's known that Radomus has met and lost his soul mate, so what if losing him/her/xyr left him in a state of depression to the point where he didn't know if he could even take care of Anna and Noel? If I was in his shoes and would have just lost my Soul Mate I wouldn't be sure if I would be fir to take care of 2 children either. And since he seems to have a little bit of an issue when it comes to neighbours and close to home family an Orphanage would be the best place. The reason he never picked them up could be that Sigmund never let him. Granted it's a little far fetched but I will stick with it untill I have seen hard proof in the game itself that he's not their father, there are simply too many pointers to him being the one in his dialog and the way Sirius and Ellias talk about both Radomus and the mystery father. Radomus is a strange person, he's probably smart and wise enough to outplay Robin from Fire Emblem awakening when it comes to strategic thinking. Yet he also knows how to act, and probably how to play a fool. I believe that in his meeting with Serius he took on said role of a fool. Another reason I'm certain Radomus is the daddy is quite simple, his interest in the Amethyst Pendant, in the part of the game where you go to save Gardevoir he acts nonchallant untill he hears about Anna's Pendant. He had turned away from El/Adrienn(not 100% sure who it was anymore, been a while since I played that part) but once of all thing the Amethyst Pendant is mentioned he turned to the one speaking of it and seems suprised to hear about it, yet he knew about it before. He also Mentions that it holds vallue to him, proving that either he knew their father or he IS their father.

 

Sorry if this seems like a little rant on the subject, I simply feel quite strongly about it and like to pull everything out when I speak about the subject. also ICSW I hope this can show you my perspective on how he would be their father and taken them to a saver place. it would for one also explain why you can't find him anywhere.

[Ice Cream Sand Witch 1650]

23 minutes ago, Wolfox Glace said:

I have a theory about that aswell. It's known that Radomus has met and lost his soul mate, so what if losing him/her/xyr left him in a state of depression to the point where he didn't know if he could even take care of Anna and Noel? If I was in his shoes and would have just lost my Soul Mate I wouldn't be sure if I would be fir to take care of 2 children either. And since he seems to have a little bit of an issue when it comes to neighbours and close to home family an Orphanage would be the best place. The reason he never picked them up could be that Sigmund never let him. Granted it's a little far fetched but I will stick with it untill I have seen hard proof in the game itself that he's not their father, there are simply too many pointers to him being the one in his dialog and the way Sirius and Ellias talk about both Radomus and the mystery father. Radomus is a strange person, he's probably smart and wise enough to outplay Robin from Fire Emblem awakening when it comes to strategic thinking. Yet he also knows how to act, and probably how to play a fool. I believe that in his meeting with Serius he took on said role of a fool. Another reason I'm certain Radomus is the daddy is quite simple, his interest in the Amethyst Pendant, in the part of the game where you go to save Gardevoir he acts nonchallant untill he hears about Anna's Pendant. He had turned away from El/Adrienn(not 100% sure who it was anymore, been a while since I played that part) but once of all thing the Amethyst Pendant is mentioned he turned to the one speaking of it and seems suprised to hear about it, yet he knew about it before. He also Mentions that it holds vallue to him, proving that either he knew their father or he IS their father.

 

Sorry if this seems like a little rant on the subject, I simply feel quite strongly about it and like to pull everything out when I speak about the subject. also ICSW I hope this can show you my perspective on how he would be their father and taken them to a saver place. it would for one also explain why you can't find him anywhere.

The Amethyst Pendant is the main reason why I can see why people think he's their father. 

 

I don't think Sigmund not letting him and Radomus just accepting that is very likely. But if it were for example "His state of mind at the time clouded his sharp critical thinking/strategic abilities", I could believe that. Or if he did know about it but still thought it was the "lesser of two evils" between that and being chased by Team Meteor, which is something I considered after making my last post. Although if he did know, he probably could've made legal threats to Sigmund or hypnotized him into not doing it.

[Wolfox 2093]

again, just spitballing with my side of the theory, just trying to show my side of it and it seems quite likely if all is put in one line, but we'll have to wait for the game to reveal it either way~